Having read article after article about these two for two years now. I always end up with the same two questions in my head. Two questions that always amaze me nobody else asks .... Why ?

The first is regarding the night at the Tappas Bar. When Jane Tanner left and while returning to the Bar, seen a man carrying what she later said could have been Maddy ..... How ? I thought she had just been to check if Maddy and the other children were OK. And if she had just checked them, then the person could not have been carrying Maddy .... unless Jane Tanner passed Maddy to them !

The second question also involves the Tappas Bar. Just how many nights did this group gather drinking, eating and merrymaking. While their children were left alone. If they were seen by others to have left their children alone on other nights.... do they not think they were playing Russian Roulette with their kids lives !

Or are we to believe that the one night they left them alone, the unthinkable happened ?